| Angus Eve | TRI |
| No. | Name | Club |
| 1 | Marvin Phillip | Morvant Caledonia United |
| 21 | Nicklas Frenderup | Ranheim Fotball |
| 22 | Adrian Foncette | Police FC |
| No. | Name | Club |
| 2 | Aubrey David | Deportivo Saprissa |
| 4 | Jelani Peters | Pittsburgh Riverhounds |
| 5 | Curtis Gonzales | Defence Force FC |
| 6 | Radanfah Abu Bakr | Churchill Brothers |
| 15 | Neveal Hackshaw | Indy Eleven |
| 16 | Alvin Jones | Real Monarchs |
| 17 | Justin García | Defence Force FC |
| 18 | Tristan Hodge | Colorado Springs Switchbacks |
| 19 | Ross Russell | La Horquetta Rangers |
| 23 | Jesse Williams | Defence Force FC |
| No. | Name | Club |
| 3 | Hashim Arcia | Defence Force FC |
| 8 | Khaleem Hyland | Al-Batin FC |
| 10 | Kevin Molino | Columbus Crew |
| 11 | Judah García | NEROCA FC |
| 13 | Reon Moore | Defence Force FC |
| 14 | Andre Fortune II | Memphis 901 |
| 20 | Duane Muckette | Memphis 901 |
| No. | Name | Club |
| 7 | Ryan Telfer | Atlético Ottawa |
| 9 | Marcus Joseph | Mohammedan SC |
| 12 | Isaiah Lee | La Horquetta Rangers |